• Add
    Company

From Shortage to Surplus: Oil’s Slippery Voyage

Libertex

Few markets have flipped quite as dramatically as crude oil in recent weeks. Brent is currently trading around $92 a barrel this morning (19 November), while WTI hovers near a local minimum of $83. Over the past month alone, Brent has dropped more than 16%. Although it remains 44% higher than a year ago, this price is still well below the $120.88 peak hit on 30 April during the height of the Hormuz crisis. Driving this sudden decline, crude shipments through the Strait of Hormuz have largely returned to pre-war levels.

Furthermore, the IEA reported last week that global supply has just overtaken demand for the first time since the Iran war began. Nevertheless, the conflict has not officially ended. An LPG tanker was struck by a projectile off Oman on Monday, and Bahrain—host to the US Fifth Fleet—intercepted Iranian aerial attacks on Wednesday. Meanwhile, Houthi forces claim to have launched five drones at two pumping stations on Saudi Arabia’s East-West pipeline.

This tension between a loosening physical market and ongoing geopolitical conflict defines the current trading environment. Oil is no longer trading purely on supply-shock mechanics; instead, prices reflect a race between a recovering supply side and a deeply disrupted demand picture, alongside a shrunken yet persistent risk premium. In this piece, we examine the potential scale of the eventual surplus, explore why the path toward it remains unpredictable, and highlight additional market catalysts that could sway valuations in the interim.

Libertex: From Shortage to Surplus: Oil’s Slippery Voyage

Gulf barrels return faster than demand

Figures from the IEA’s November report illustrate this shift in market sentiment. The agency projects global oil supply to recover by 6.6 million barrels per day to reach 108.1 million in 2027. This expansion includes a 5.3 million barrel increase from the Gulf alongside another 1.1 million barrels from the “Quintet” (the US, Canada, Brazil, Argentina, and Guyana). Demand, by contrast, is rebuilding slowly after a year of disruption: consumption is forecast to contract by 2.7 million barrels per day in 2026 to 102.3 million before eventually rebounding by 2 million in 2027, leaving an estimated surplus of roughly 3.8 million barrels per day next year. Closer analysis reveals that even this rebound is quite narrow. LPG and petrochemical feedstocks (ethane and naphtha) account for nearly 80% of projected demand growth, whereas transport fuels like diesel and petrol are expected to expand only modestly. Weekly figures already reflect this emerging glut. Global inventories rose by 52 million barrels in October, and US crude stocks increased by 3.4 million barrels last week alone—far exceeding the analyst consensus of a 58,000-barrel build. Even so, stockpiles remain approximately 3% below their five-year seasonal average, and Cushing hub reserves fell by 1.2 million barrels. Official forecasters maintain a cautious stance regarding the pace of further declines. The EIA anticipates prices will drift downward to an average of $77 in Q4 2027 as depleted inventories rebuild, though it warns that Middle Eastern flows remain vulnerable to disruption and short-term volatility could exceed monthly projections. Goldman Sachs similarly projects a 2027 surplus with prices nearing $78 by year-end. Consequently, medium-term fundamentals point toward a downward trend, albeit with a crucial caveat: forecasts predicated on normalizing flows depend entirely on the stability of the ceasefire, as recent fighting highlights.

Multiple factors indicate that the trajectory toward a surplus will be far bumpier than headline figures suggest. Chief among these is the physical location of stored crude. Most of October’s inventory accumulation occurred aboard ocean vessels rather than onshore storage tanks. In line with this, the IEA highlights refined diesel availability as a primary concern, while elevated freight rates have compressed refining margins for Asian buyers. Similarly, the EIA noted that extended shipping routes and heightened disruption risks restrict how quickly global stocks can reach spot markets. Consequently, this surplus exists largely on paper and may take time to relieve tightness in downstream refined products. A secondary catalyst stems from macroeconomic conditions. Expectations of higher US interest rates continue to weigh on energy markets by threatening economic expansion, dampening demand, and strengthening the US dollar, which renders dollar-denominated crude more expensive for international buyers. With a December Fed rate hike largely priced in, market participants are watching whether monetary tightening concludes or extends into 2027. This dynamic brings OPEC+ into focus. While the cartel’s seven core members held December production targets steady on 1 November, the upcoming ministerial meeting on 29 November will establish the output framework for 2027. Should members choose to restore production volumes, surplus concerns could exert further downward pressure on prices; conversely, maintaining output cuts risks ceding market share to American producers. Natural gas, by comparison, exhibits lower volatility. The EIA lowered its winter Henry Hub forecast to an average of $2.87 per million BTU for November 2026 through March 2027, representing a 16% reduction from last month's projection.

With prices hovering near $3.2, heating demand remains a weather-dependent upside factor rather than a structural supply concern. Ultimately, energy investors face a market where medium-term fundamentals are loosening, yet short-term price action will remain driven by geopolitical developments in the Gulf, the Fed’s December interest rate decision, and the OPEC+ conference at month-end. Several factors mean the path to that surplus is likely to be bumpier than the headline numbers would suggest. The first is where the oil physically lies. Most of October’s inventory build was aboard ships rather than in storage tanks, and the IEA still states that diesel is its overriding concern, while record freight costs squeezed refining margins for Asian buyers. The EIA similarly noted that longer shipping routes and the heightened risk of disruption limit how much of the global stock build can reach the real market in the near term. In effect, this means that the surplus exists on paper for a long time before it is able to actually ease tightness in the refined-product markets that consumers actually pay for. The second factor is macro in nature. Expectations of higher US interest rates are weighing on oil, as they threaten economic growth and demand and strengthen the dollar, making crude more expensive for non-US buyers. A December Fed hike is now pretty much nailed on, so the question for oil is whether the tightening cycle ends there or continues into 2027. This then brings us to OPEC+. The cartel’s seven core members held December targets steady on 1 November, but the ministerial meeting on 29 November is where we will see the 2027 production framework set. If they choose to restore volumes, surplus risks will push prices lower, but if they hold back, it means ceding market share to the American producers. Natural gas, meanwhile, is much less volatile. The EIA has lowered its winter Henry Hub forecast to an average of $2.87 per million BTU for November 2026 to March 2027, which is 16% below last month’s estimate. Prices have been hovering around $3.2, which leaves heating demand as a weather-dependent upside risk rather than a supply concern. For oil investors, the picture is of a market whose medium-term fundamentals are loosening, but whose near-term price action will still be dictated by headlines from the Gulf, the Fed’s December decision, and OPEC+’s Sunday meeting at the end of the month.

Disclaimer
!"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|} !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}